The Benedicts left the auction this year with starters at every offensive position and a decent pitching staff anchored by Aaron Harang, Mike Pelfrey, John Maine and Jonathan Sanchez in the rotation and Jonathan Broxton and Carlos Marmol in the bullpen. The team looked good on paper, but needed work to compete for the title (don't they all). The Benedicts on the field have now spent better than a week either in last place or very near it.
Meanwhile, the Kaos are in first place. The Kaos are built around Albert Pujols and Carlos Beltran, a trio of last year's Benedict rejects (Ryan Zimmerman, Chris Duncan, Adam LaRoche -- all keys to the team's race to the cellar last year) and reserve players like Fernando Tatis, Blake DeWitt, Jerry Hairston, and Nate Schierholtz. The Kaos's best pitchers are Johnny Cueto (4.81, 1.414 in 2008) and Jason Marquis (4.59, 1.449 last year - now in Colorado).
The Benedict players are underachieving in such a uniform fashion that it is hard to believe the performances are not a plot.
Milton Bradley, a .321 hitter last year and a .306 hitter the year before, is hitting .170 through May 11. Carlos Delgado struggled again in April and like clockwork, began to complain about an injured hip. The Benedicts reserved him and he went on a tear, hitting over .400 with an OPS over 1.100 (!) in 26 at bats. He returned to the team's active roster yesterday only to proclaim immediately that his hip is again hurt. He is out of the line up indefinately. Delgado's road to Cooperstown does not run through the Benedicts' active roster.
Brian Giles, who hit .306 last season, is hitting .158. He has been reserved to make room for Stephen Drew, returning from an injury. The smart money says Giles has the week of his life this week.
Someone reading this might wonder how Adam Dunn and Ryan Theriot missed the memo.
Meanwhile, the pitching staff is in shambles -- Mike Pelfrey, who pitched so brilliantly after July 1 last year (3.15 ERA, 1.140 ratio) has stumbled to 5.46, 1.714 this year. Andrew Miller (6.94, 1.886) continues to be a train wreck - a shadow of the dominant pitcher he was in college. Sanchez, still a promising pitcher, has inexplicably walked 22 batters in 26 innings this year (he walked 75 in 158 last year). Yusmeiro Petit, another promising pitcher last year (4.31, 1.037 in 19 games, 8 starts), has ballooned to 8.14, 1.767.
Even Carlos Marmol, virtually unhittable the last two seasons (2.13 ERA, 1.002 ratio, 12.06 K/9IP) has been affected by this curse (4.20 ERA, 1.600 ratio this year).
In shades of 2006 and Takashi Saito, the Benedicts missed on the Jorge De La Rosa bidding by one dollar.
The league's history has examples where teams have rallied from the depths in May to win the title or finish competitively. The 1990 Benedicts, lodged in 7th place in mid-May, rallied to the title; the famous Boards championship team in the 1990s came from last to first over that period with the never-again-tried One Dollar Pitching Staff.
The Benedicts have been shopping Colby Rasmus, which tells us they are not going to throw in the towel early this year. So far, these offers are discussion-phase only. There have been no signs of Adam Dunn going on the block. This may well be a do-or-die, all-or-nothing year for the Benedicts.
Labels: Team Notes